OK, so I already told you the setup for "Reaper," and the big deep subtle reasons why it works. Now let me tell you why it's so puppy-dog likable and why I think it's better than "Chuck." And then if you're still not convinced that you should watch the premiere tonight on CW, I will come to your house and change the channel for you.
And by the way, a caveat: I am an insane "House" fan, and "Reaper" airs opposite it. If you don't get reviewer DVDs of both shows (nyeah nyeah) or have a DVR, I understand this is going to be a difficult decision. But if you must choose just one show tonight, consider that "House" is, deservedly, a giant-ass hit, and "Reaper" is a brand new series on a dinky little also-ran network. Who needs your help more? When I'm done with this post, I'll share a few spoilers about tonight's "House," too.
So why "Reaper?" Five more reasons:
1) The leading man. Bret Harrison was the best thing about the wildly uneven Fox sitcom "The Loop," a put-upon everyman wading through a horde of scenery-chewing loonies. There were great moments on that show, and also scenes so bad I changed the channel. Here his pained looks and yelps of outrage are in the service of a much more finely calibrated script that actually makes sense from scene to scene. And he's like, a real guy, not a cartoon. His wounded innocence and nascent courage here provide the grounding for all...the...crazy....shit.
Pictured: Rick Gonzalez as Ben, Bret Harrison as Sam, and Tyler Labine as Sock, from episode two.